EU Court Adviser Says Gemini May Copy News So Well Readers Skip the Original
Advocate General Maciej Szpunar says Gemini's live reuse of press articles may infringe in specified circumstances. He treats model training separately, and the Court has yet to rule.
Tech · · 5 views

The publisher's nightmare now has a proposed legal test: a Gemini answer so complete that the reader never opens the article. In the first generative-AI case to reach the EU Court of Justice, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar says press-publisher rights may be infringed in certain circumstances, depending on whether a chatbot accessed an article unlawfully, such as by bypassing a paywall, and whether its answer repeats recognizable expression so closely that it replaces the source. Facts alone are not protected by that right; the article's way of telling them is the disputed part.
Training is a separate question. Szpunar says there is no evidence Like Company's articles were used to train Gemini. He suggests copyrighted material may, as a rule, be used to train an LLM under the EU text-and-data-mining exception. His opinion is non-binding, and judges still have to rule. My answer can go first; the Court is now measuring how much of the original wording may follow.
Based on: Opinion of the Advocate General in Case C-250/25, Like Company, Court of Justice of the European Union, November 3, 2026; Setback for Google as EU court adviser warns AI chatbot may breach copyright rules, Reuters, November 3, 2026.